More Walter Reed Fallout: Army Secretary Francis J. Harvey Resigns

By: cycle12
Published On: 3/3/2007 10:27:30 AM

As expected and predicted, heads have continued to roll over the Walter Reed and outpatient care situations as Army Secretary Francis J. Harvey abruptly resigned yesterday, effective Friday, March 9, with just one week notice.

Read all about it at this link:

http://news.yahoo.co...

And the full text of the article is available below...
-------------------------------------------------
"Walter Reed furor claims Army secretary
By LOLITA C. BALDOR, AP Military Writer

"WASHINGTON - It began with reports of mice and moldy plaster, but after two weeks of outrage, the scandal over poor conditions at Walter Reed Army Medical Center has claimed several careers - including the secretary of the Army's.

"Secretary Francis J. Harvey's abrupt dismissal Friday came under withering criticism from  Pentagon chief Robert Gates, who said the Army's response to the substandard conditions for the war-wounded was defensive, and not aggressive enough. And it left the door open for more personnel changes, as investigations continue and Congress prepares for hearings next week.

"Harvey's departure was the most dramatic move during two weeks of furor over the treatment of soldiers at one of the military's highest-profile and busiest medical facilities.

"President Bush has ordered a comprehensive review of conditions at the nation's network of military and veteran hospitals, which has been overwhelmed by injured troops from the wars in Iraq and Afghanistan.

"Gates said Harvey had resigned, but senior defense officials, speaking on condition of anonymity, said Gates had privately demanded that Harvey leave. Gates was displeased that the officer Harvey had chosen as interim commander of Walter Reed - Lt. Gen. Kevin Kiley, the current Army surgeon general and a former commander of Walter Reed - has been accused by critics of long knowing about the problems there and not improving outpatient care.

"'I am disappointed that some in the Army have not adequately appreciated the seriousness of the situation pertaining to outpatient care at Walter Reed,'" Gates said in the Pentagon briefing room. He took no questions from reporters.

"Harvey was at Fort Benning, Ga., on Friday morning when he cut short his visit to return to Washington to meet with Gates.

"In an interview in his office shortly after the announcement, Harvey said he offered Gates his resignation because he believed the Army had let the wounded soldiers down. He said the furor has depressed the staff at Walter Reed, and he wanted to prevent any others from leaving or being fired.

"'We can't have them leave,'" he said. "'We can't have them be so demoralized that they leave. So I figured, what the heck, if I offer my resignation that may stop all this bleeding, and it was accepted.'"

"Asked if Gates had prodded him to leave, Harvey acknowledged the secretary wasn't happy with the way the Army had handled the matter. But he said he had been thinking about stepping down for a few days.

"'I submitted my resignation,'" Harvey said, and added: "'We let the soldiers down, I'm the head of the Army. I thought it was necessary to do that.'"

"On Thursday, Harvey fired the medical center's previous commander, Maj. Gen. George Weightman, for failures linked to the outpatient treatment controversy. Many had speculated that Weightman would be relieved of command, but Harvey's departure was a surprise. His last day in the job will be March 9."

"In addition, the Army took disciplinary action against several lower-level soldiers at Walter Reed, but officials have declined to publicly confirm any details of those actions.

"Peter Geren, the undersecretary of the Army, will serve as Harvey's temporary replacement until Bush nominates a new secretary.

"As Army secretary, Harvey is the service's top civilian official. He commands no troops. Along with the four-star general who is Army chief of staff, the secretary has statutory responsibility for training and equipping the Army. That includes responsibility for budgeting, recruiting and other personnel and resource policies.

"The Army announced Friday that Maj. Gen. Eric B. Schoomaker, 58, will be the new commander of Walter Reed, which is located in Washington.

"'From what I have learned, the problems at Walter Reed appear to be problems of leadership,'" Gates said. "'The Walter Reed doctors, nurses and other staff are among the best and most caring in the world. They deserve our continued deepest thanks and strongest support.'"

"The revelations about shoddy facilities and wounded soldiers enduring long waits for treatment have embarrassed the Army and the Bush administration at a time when the White House is scrambling to shore up eroding support for the Iraq war. They have prompted numerous calls in Congress for more information, and sullied the reputation of what is supposed to be one of the military's foremost medical facilities.

"An internal memo from Weightman last fall requested funding and additional personnel, saying that if shortfalls and the loss of skilled staff were not addressed, "patient care services are at risk of mission failure.'"

"Rep. Ike Skelton, D-Mo., chairman of the House Armed Services Committee, applauded Harvey's departure.

"'I commend him for taking responsibility for the problems at Walter Reed,'" Skelton said.

"The defense secretary indicated he was unhappy with the way Army leaders had responded to the Walter Reed disclosures.

"'Some have shown too much defensiveness and have not shown enough focus on digging into and addressing the problems,'" Gates said.

"'Also I am concerned that some do not properly understand the need to communicate to the wounded and their families that we have no higher priority than their care and that addressing their concerns about the quality of their outpatient experience is critically important. Our wounded soldiers and their families have sacrificed much and they deserve the best we can offer.'"

"The White House said the president would name a bipartisan commission to assess whether the problems at Walter Reed exist at other facilities. Last week, Gates created an outside panel to review the situation at Walter Reed and the other major military hospital in the Washington area, the National Naval Medical Center at Bethesda, Md.

"The actions came after The Washington Post documented squalid living conditions for some outpatient soldiers at Walter Reed and bureaucratic problems that prevented many troops from getting adequate care.

"Harvey has been Army secretary since November 2004.

"He is the second Bush administration Army secretary to be removed abruptly from office. In April 2003, Defense Secretary Donald H. Rumsfeld fired Thomas White, who had engaged in public disputes with Rumsfeld.

"A former businessman trained as an engineer, Harvey counted as one of his proudest achievements a turnaround of the Army's recent recruiting slump. In 2005, the Army missed its recruiting goal for the first time since 1999, and that same year Harvey instituted a series of changes that led to a recovery in recruiting."

___

AP Military Writer Robert Burns contributed to this report.
-------------------------------------------------
There you have it, so please stay tuned...

Thanks!

Steve


Comments



leadership begins at the top (accidentalwoman - 3/3/2007 5:38:56 PM)
The absolute failure of leadership from this administration began in the white house. The infamous Rumsfeld was sheltered by George Bush in the face of his overwhelming failures. They created a culture in which a strenuous effort to fight for the adequate care of troops would result only in the loss of command.

It is interesting that Weightman (recently relieved commanding Gen. of Walter Reed) requested additional resources, with the warning that mission failure might occur without them. (See the email referenced in the article above). I think that was a very clear message directly to the sec of the army and to the army chief of staff that there were problems.

These resignations and dismissals are necessary in spite of the fact that the real responsibility lies with an administration more concerned with rhetoric than with the quality of care received by wounded soldiers. This needs to get bloody for the well being of the service and the country. The chief of staff of the army should be relieved as well. The office of the sec of defense has become far too consumed by its own power and image in the same way that the executive branch has become completely self- absorbed.

  Military officers walk a fine line in the need to obey orders and the need to do the right thing. The risk and reality of sacrifice change with rank but the loss of a career is not more important than the loss of life.  If loss of life is willingly offered by lower ranking soldiers it is only appropriate that higher ranking officers are willing to risk their careers in order to protect those soldiers and to protect this country. Gen Shinseki spoke truth to power prior to the invasion of Iraq and was "offered early retirement". He made a great sacrifice and those behind him were not willing to do so.

Congress needs to establish its own bipartisan commission to monitor the quality of care extended to all veterans. The president's commission is unlikely to evaluate the care received by Iraq and Afghanistan war vets after they leave the service. The spotlight is on the care being received by injured veterans who are still on active duty but those same veterans will have to leave this system and pass into the V.A system which is equally unprepared to meet its increasing client needs. The plight of veterans transiting from one system to the other has been documented and must be addressed.

In short, if this issue has a short msm life it will not result in meaningful change.



I smell Halliburton? (beachydem - 3/4/2007 6:25:52 PM)
And why was Walter Reed put on the BRAC list during A WAR?

So much to digest while Republicans are "supporting the troops".  Sigh.



I *smelled* right.... (beachydem - 3/4/2007 7:00:00 PM)
http://www.armytimes...


Excellent find, "beachydem"... (cycle12 - 3/4/2007 7:45:39 PM)
...especially these two paragraphs from the Army Times article to which you supplied the link above:
----------------------------------------------------------
"The memorandum "'describes how the Army's decision to privatize support services at Walter Reed Army Medical Center was causing an exodus of `highly skilled and experienced personnel,'" the committee's letter states. "'According to multiple sources, the decision to privatize support services at Walter Reed led to a precipitous drop in support personnel at Walter Reed.'"

"The letter said Walter Reed also awarded a five-year, $120-million contract to IAP Worldwide Services, which is run by Al Neffgen, a former senior Halliburton official."
-----------------------------------------------------------
Please take the time to read the entire Army Times article.  If it weren't so typical these days, I'd say that it is amazing! 

(Stay the course, George; stay the course...)

Steve