Sabato: Allen "Did Use the N-Word" [UPDATED]

By: Greg Greene
Published On: 9/25/2006 7:07:21 PM

... and the good professor dropped that bombshell on the national airwaves today, by way of Chris Matthews' Hardball. Asked whether Allen used the word with racist intent, Allen classmate Larry Sabato said (emphasis mine): "I'm going to stay with what I know is the case. And the fact is, he did use the n-word, whether he's denying it now or not. He did use it."

YouTube has the clip:

Game over for the A-Team? Mebbe not – but I have a hard time seeing why Sabato would risk his credibility as a media go-to guy by venturing out on a limb with this. The Salon article just gained a heck of a lot more credibility.

Update, 7:45 p.m.: Just found a longer clip -- I've saved it in the extended section ...

Update, 8:20 p.m.: More after the jump, from the comments (thanks, PM and bb10 – another witness has the N-word emerging from Allen's mouth ...


[A]nother former acquaintance of the senator's has come forward, saying that Allen once used the word "nigger" in his presence in the early '80s. Chris Taylor, a University of Alabama professor of anthropology, says the incident occurred in about 1981 or 1982, when Taylor (then a UVA graduate student) visited Allen (then a Virginia attorney just beginning his political career) at Allen's cabin in Earlysville, Virginia.

Taylor told his account of Allen's use of the N-word in a private email to a UVA colleague last month. The email was recently obtained by The New Republic. Taylor confirmed the authenticity of the email and reluctantly agreed to speak on the record about the incident.

Wow.


Comments



Way to Go, Greg ! (Al Rodgers - 9/25/2006 7:09:41 PM)


Channel 9 News -- Viewer Emails (Greg - 9/25/2006 7:14:52 PM)
Derek McGinty just mentioned that the Allen n-word issue would be featured on tonight's 'Mailbag' -- where they quote from viewer emails -- at the end of the 7 PM newscast and again on the 11 PM show. Y'all know what to do. (Would probably be more effective if you don't all mention the blog.)

The address is mailto: 9newstonight@wusa9.com



Full MSNBC / Sabato vid. (Bubby - 9/25/2006 7:15:33 PM)
http://www.msnbc.msn...

Larry knows more than he will say...



Yes, Bubby, it's mysterious (PM - 9/25/2006 7:38:39 PM)
He wouldn't say if had personally heard it, but he seemed to hint he knew something else; and it seemed as if he said something about Allen maybe using it on TV?  He stood by the article's conclusion on the N word and emphasized that Shelton was a stand-up guy.

Chris Mathews came across well on this one.  He said being raised in Philly, in a racially divided town, people did not use it

But definitely Sabato seems to know something more.  And it is a courageous stand, because now they'll attack Sabato.

This is the reason there are so few whistleblowers in DC.  Lots of people have seen illegal, dirty things but they know the consequences if they speak.



Thank god for Tenure (Bubby - 9/25/2006 7:59:07 PM)
The Republican Party of Virginia has a choice to make. The road to ruin, or the road to renewal.  It's way past time for that reckoning. They are in the ditch with Allen's wagon.


Wow. This is huge. (Leaves on the Current - 9/25/2006 7:31:02 PM)
Sabato knew Allen in college, and he's saying this is "what I know."  Eyewitness testimony from a very, very credible source.

This is such an inflammatory issue, Sabato deserves a lot of credit for having the guts to be so honest.  Because he just became anathema to the entire GOP--not a good place for the nation's go-to politics professor to be.

Thanks, Prof. Sabato.  You just did something very good and courageous for Virginia.



Class of 1974 (Greg - 9/25/2006 8:54:05 PM)
That's the key talking point about this, folks. Sabato was in the same graduating class at University of Virginia, and it's a relatively small student body for a state university.


game, set, match (TurnVirginiaBlue - 9/25/2006 7:33:03 PM)
While I prefer the issues to rein in a campaign and there is no doubt that Webb is the better candidate, I think this is game, set match to be frank.

He's never going to recover from these sorts of stories.



I turned on Hardball (lwumom - 9/25/2006 7:39:18 PM)
just in time to catch the interview!  (It's on tape- delayed here in SoCal, apparently)  This is huge!  Sabato did make the comment that he didn't think this would affect the election, but how could it not?  Considering how Allen's poll numbers declined after the "M" word, why would the case be any different after the "N" word story broke?  Alot of conservatives may have been willing to give Allen the benefit of the doubt, but after hearing the word from Sabato, how can they ignore it?  I think that at the very least, you may find some people who will vote for Allen, but they won't admit it, because to admit it would be to admit that they condone racism.

I can hardly wait to see what Olbermann has to say!



I heard Olberman (Gordie - 9/25/2006 10:03:20 PM)
What a fantastic defense of Clinton and prase for to Clinton for saying what so many of us thought. Now that a highly respected commentator spoke about the 8 months before 9/11 I am hoping the truth starts to fly and really stops this spin about Republicans are better then Democrats when it comes to Terrorism.
Can hardly wait for the segment to be posted.


At least Bill Clinton said he tried! (lwumom - 9/25/2006 10:12:18 PM)
He had the same ambiguous intelligence that the Bush Administration "said" they acted upon to invade Iraq.  The difference is....he knew the right thing to do.  A president can't risk creating an international incident on ambiguous information....or at least "the president" didn't leap before looking before the bush administration.


Larry's been wrong a time or two. (Kathy Gerber - 9/25/2006 10:11:54 PM)
He took a little while to get his head around the whole idea of fighting Dems, too.  Not to worry :)


Full link here-- (Leaves on the Current - 9/25/2006 7:42:47 PM)
Here's the entire Sabato-Matthews interchange:

http://www.msnbc.msn...

It doesn't take a rocket scientist to read between the lines.



Another witness emerges, and yet another to come (PM - 9/25/2006 7:57:42 PM)
http://www.nytimes.c...

Christopher Taylor, an anthropology professor at Auburn University in Birmingham, Ala., said that in the early 1980’s he heard Mr. Allen use an inflammatory epithet for African Americans. Mr. Taylor, who is white and was then a graduate student at the University of Virginia in Charlottesville, said the term came up in a conversation about the turtles in a pond near Mr. Allen’s property. According to Mr. Taylor, Mr. Allen said that “around here” only the African Americans — whom he referred to by the epithet — “eat ‘em.”

And Josh Marshall says there's another witness about to come forward:
http://www.talkingpo...

(He seems to be saying the new person that talked to the New York Times is not the "new" witness he was referring to -- a bit confusing)



Diet. (Kathy Gerber - 9/25/2006 10:28:15 PM)
Talk about digging a hole.  As much as I hate to expand on this, that's what I learned growing up, too.  But the phrase was "colored people."  Not that much better, but at least a stab in the directin of civility for the times.

There is a local divergence in dietary tradition that reflects the extreme class differences.  Turtle is just one, carp is another. (don't get me started on shad..)

This really speaks to the authenticity of the witness.  And it lends credibility to the deer head in the mailbox, too.

Thanks for all these links.



At the very least-- (Steven J. Berke - 9/25/2006 8:02:55 PM)
-AT THE VERY LEAST--this guarantees that the African-American vote will swing behind Jim Webb practically to a man and woman.  Never mind Benjamin Lambert or the black preachers who appeared with Allen today to endorse the gay marriage amendment.  Black voters are not going to let someone with that kind of background and mentality stay in the United States Senate if they can help it.

That does not mean, however, that Jim Webb can afford to take the African American vote, or any vote, for granted.  There is still some courtship and discussion to be done.



Your Point Is Well Taken (Used2Bneutral - 9/26/2006 5:57:05 AM)
Now the Republican response to a situation like this falls into their "Alternate" 72 hour plan for November.... they will play that many more dirty tricks to SUPPRESS the vote from the black community.... This is exactly what they did against Kerry, this is what they did against Kaine and they certainly won't changed their stripes this year.....

Remember the documented dirty trick played against incumbant Alexandria area Delegate Mark Sickles last year who enjoyed an eighty percent approval rating from his entire voter base.  They figured the only way to beat Mark was to "Kill" him. So, as stupid as it sounds and as funny as they thought it was, what they did at the last minute the night before the election was to place a "Robo-Dial" to all the voters in Mark's district claiming that Mark had just died suddenly and to just go ahead and vote for the other guy on the ballot. Granted, this had limited effect, but if this trick suppressed ONE VOTE it should have been a felony that was prosecuted. Or the old suppression trick that is especially effect in a non-presidential year with bad weather of slashing the tires on the "voter transportation" buses and vans the very early morning of the elections.... "if you can't change their minds, then keeping them from voting" seems to be the strategy that they have resorted to for years.



More on Chris Taylor (PM - 9/25/2006 8:04:14 PM)
He made the charge privately last month:

http://www.tnr.com/d...

n August 17, 2006, in the midst of the media frenzy over Allen's use of the word macaca to address an Indian-American, Taylor wrote to Frederick H. Damon, the Director of Graduate Studies at UVA's Department of Anthropology. Taylor, who, as a UVA graduate student, earned extra money by doing publicity photo shoots for local businesses, told the following story about meeting Allen:

I met him twice actaully [sic]. I did two modelling [sic] jobs with his then wife and she told me about some puppies they were trying to give away. I told her I'd like to take one. So one evening I went out to their place in the country near [Charlottesville] somewhere. There was a pond quite close by. I asked if they had any waterfowl landing there. George told me about the ducks and geese that sometimes landed there and about the ducks who tried to raise their young but who would have them all devoured by the big turtles in the pond. Well, why doesn't someone kill the turtles and eat them? I asked. George said 'only the niggers around here eat em.'

Last night, Salon's Michael Scherer reported that three members of Allen's college football team said Allen regularly used the N-word in college. One of the players, Ken Shelton, now a North Carolina radiologist, also said that Allen stuffed the head of a deer in a black family's mailbox. On Monday, Allen told the Associated Press, "The story and his comments and assertions in there are completely false."

An email request for comment sent to four Allen staffers regarding the new accusations from Taylor was not returned by early Monday evening. The only other witness to the exchange, Allen's first wife Anne Allen, could not be reached for comment.

Asked recently about his political leanings, Taylor, who initially requested that his story about Allen not be publicized because he feared legal action from the senator, responded, "I'm a Democrat. And I certainly want to see his [Allen's] opponent elected." Asked if he intended his e-mail to become public, Taylor laughed. "No, it was Fred Damon who decided to tell all these other people."

Many details of Taylor's account were independently confirmed by The New Republic. Taylor explained that he met Anne Allen during a modeling job for the Barracks Road Shopping Center, a well-known retail destination in Charlottesville. According to Bob Gibson, a political writer at the Charlottesville Daily Progress who has covered Allen for almost three decades, Anne Allen was indeed a model in the early '80s. According to a person who lives near the Allen cabin, which the senator no longer owns, "the property does have a manmade pond on it."



I heard a rumor that (lwumom - 9/25/2006 10:48:55 PM)
Anne Patrice Rubel Allen lived in La Jolla, CA.  I live about 15 minutes from La Jolla..... 


New Allegations in TNR Article Just Posted (bb10 - 9/25/2006 8:06:12 PM)
There are new allegations against Allen in a Ryan Lizza story for the The New Republic (see here). Here's how the story begins:

In the wake of allegations that Virginia Senator George Allen repeatedly used the word "nigger" as a college student at the University of Virginia in the 1970s, the senator today issued a blanket denial that he has ever uttered the word. "I don't remember ever using that word and it is absolutely false that that was ever part of my vocabulary," Allen told the Associated Press Monday.

But now another former acquaintance of the senator's has come forward, saying that Allen once used the word "nigger" in his presence in the early '80s. Chris Taylor, a University of Alabama professor of anthropology, says the incident occurred in about 1981 or 1982, when Taylor (then a UVA graduate student) visited Allen (then a Virginia attorney just beginning his political career) at Allen's cabin in Earlysville, Virginia.

Taylor told his account of Allen's use of the N-word in a private email to a UVA colleague last month. The email was recently obtained by The New Republic. Taylor confirmed the authenticity of the email and reluctantly agreed to speak on the record about the incident.

Earlier today, Allen was looking like toast. Now he's looking like a pile of blackened crumbs.



New York Times is on it as well (Greg - 9/25/2006 8:59:47 PM)
Here's the link.

The pick up the Salon info and also Mr. Taylor's story.

Key points: 1) Allen was 30ish at that point, so it's less explainable as a youthful indiscretion, and 2) for all of y'all Virginia MSM folks who read this fine blog, now that the NYT has picked it up, it's a 'respectable' story -- do you want to end up running it on Wednesday when your competitors had it their Tuesday editions?



Army bugler plays Taps for Mr. Allen: (vote-left - 9/25/2006 8:21:57 PM)
http://bands.army.mi...


IT AIN'T OVER TILL IT'S OVER (ub40fan - 9/25/2006 9:07:39 PM)
I hate to say this but Allen is still in the game with some 5 weeks to go and $5 million to spend. He may look like a jackass movie moron right now but how many of those shithead types are sitting in congress these days?? More than I can stand I'm afraid. And I bet there are a lot of voting people who just aren't paying attention to this little scandal... but they pay attention to TV .... and all the negative Webb spots cascading across ones football screen.

But you've gotta Love Prof Larry Sabato for nailing a liar. It does take guts. Maybe having Sidarth sitting in his class gave him some courage. Afterall Sidarth is a really nice guy ... and George Allen is NOT. Allen is just a conceited Bully.

What I'm waiting for is when Colbert gets a hold of this .... that will be classic!!

Keep the heat on Webb Campaign!! ... Keep Allen's feet to the fire!! TOAST HIM!!



Counting Chickens (Teddy - 9/25/2006 10:18:00 PM)
before they hatch is not a good idea. So Allen has $5million left for the last 5 weeks of the campaign, which works out to, let's see... a million a week of negative advertising. Yeah, can't relax now. No question about it, the campaign must pour on the coals and go flank speed.


Yes, and that goes for the black vote, too-- (Leaves on the Current - 9/25/2006 11:52:05 PM)
--It would be both unseemly arrogant and unwise for Jim Webb to take the black vote for granted, just because Allen has surely lost it.

African Americans in Virginia have just been given a powerful reason not to vote for George Allen, yes.

But it's now the Democrats' job to persuade them that they have an equally powerful reason to vote *for* Jim Webb.

And we Dems had better not forget it.



COMMENT HIDDEN (blackamerican - 9/26/2006 9:38:09 PM)


I am glad... (vote-left - 9/26/2006 10:35:37 PM)
...that you attend to cast you vote for Allen.  I intend to cast my vote for Webb.

I don't think Allen stopped long enough to ask how the African-Americans voted before he cut off the head of a deer and stuffed it into their mailbox. 

p.s., only Allen can destroy Allen's character.  However, Allen needs to develop character before he can destroy it.



You know, at some point... (vote-left - 9/26/2006 12:41:20 AM)
...Allen crossed a line and there is no turning back.  Therefore, it is over.

Allen's lies created "wedge issues."  Unfortunately for Allen, in his case he "wedged" himself into a corner where he couldn't fight his own way out of a wet paper bag. 

If Allen had never intended to hold public office, he could have quietly lived a racist life.  However, since he has always had a desire to seek further public office, the fact that he continued to openly use racist remarks was a high risk, Las Vegas gamble.  The odds of his racism coming back to bite him were very great.

Allen's "macaca" remark was, in my opinion, a racist remark.  We have all heard many stories about Allen being a bully.  The "macaca" incident was a classic event of bullying.  Allen tried to belittle a young, minority kid in a rural area of Virginia, where Allen knew the crowd would be at least politically hostile towards Sidarth and probably racially hostile. 

Simply put, Allen was bullying Sidarth by baiting the crowd against him.  Allen created a hostile environment and he enjoyed every second of it.  Allen's racism shined that day, but Allen probably never thought at that time that it would see the light of day.  After all, he had gotten away with it for 30 years.

The fact that Allen got away with it for so many years including while he was governor and senator, probably created a false sense of grandiosity, leading him to think he could get away with pretty much anything, including his lies and then more lies to cover up the original lies.

Allen is now past a point-of-no-return.  It has snowballed to big.  And it is no longer just the racism.  It is also his Jewish heritage.  It is also his need to pathologically lie.  It is the fact that his sister said he was a bully.  And, his college classmates said he was a bully.

I am sure that Webb would like to discuss political issues and not have to hear about Allen's character.  But, the fact is, character matters and Allen is void in that area.

Candidates would prefer to win an election of their strengths.  Some candidates lose because of their weaknesses. 



What's Allen going to do now? (vote-left - 9/26/2006 12:44:42 AM)
Call Larry Sabato a liar?

It's over for Allen. 

Some people accept it sooner than others.



Posting on Salon.com (vote-left - 9/26/2006 1:48:11 AM)
George Allen and PV High

I went to Palos Verdes High School with George Allen. Ask him about the JJR (the Jesse James Revival) his un-official club where he claimed they beat up N's on Saturday nights. He kept a Dodger bat in his car with words "Nigger Knocker" written on it.For Homecoming 1967 he was saying in football practice the day before, N's going to paint the school tonight, I just know it. Sure enough, next day school painted with slurs aimed against whites (guess the ethnicity of the school we played, they won handily by the way!). He was originally expelled but reduced to suspension with agreement to pay to paint over the school. I've heard him speak N word many times in High School. Shelton is right this guy doesn't deserve to hold elected office. Ask the 1500 or so students, faculty, parents who were in Palos Verdes in 1969. I've made this post many places and waiting for media to contact me. I can verify this story with hundreds of people including his football coach at the time. I saw Coach recently at the store and we talked about the Homecoming incident.

-- thezudes

Link to Salon.com posting



man! (drmontoya - 9/25/2006 9:32:42 PM)
I hope, that colbert and jon stewart pick this up!!

will I be so lucky?

...



Stewart/Colbert (Different Drum - 9/25/2006 9:54:51 PM)
I think Stewart tapes his show in the early evening, so I don't imagine they'll have the Sabato stuff yet.  You really have to be on your toes to keep up with the Allen campaign - it's scandal at the speed of light!


I cannot understand (Arturo - 9/25/2006 9:44:12 PM)
how a man like Allen has been an elected official for so long.  How did that happen?


Good Question (VA Breeze - 9/25/2006 9:49:58 PM)
It has been a mystery to me too.


Me three on Mystery of Allen's reelections.... (bladerunner - 9/25/2006 10:34:42 PM)
Also another thing to look out for according to I believe Rozelle--Allen is depending on Religious right to come and save on "Marriage Ammendment". He'll be kissing fundamentalist butt for the next few weeks.

Well people in the bloggistphere, I am hoping that this could be the beggining of the end to One Hell of a sad chapter in Virginia's history--I am picturing the German Tanks running out of gas in the Battle of the Bulge--it was over!!!!  Felix does have some hate earned money over the years and will begin his last ditch effort in his Battle of the Bulge--but he's getting close to empty too.



Allen's advantages (DukieDem - 9/25/2006 11:30:27 PM)
Money and conservatives coming out to vote for the marriage amendment.

We can't count on winning the moderate vote; we have to DESTROY HIM with independents. Don't let up now.

42 days. Keep fighting.



Sabato Rechants (Gordie - 9/27/2006 9:33:16 AM)
All better read the AP today. Sabato has rechanted his story on Hardball and he sent an email to AP that he did not actually hear Allen say the N word.


Story has not changed (VA Breeze - 9/27/2006 9:45:16 AM)
On Hardball, Sabato didn't say he had heard the word-just he knows Allen used it. Sabato said he has reliable sources to this behavior.