Energy Debate Begins to Come into Focus in Governor's Race

By: TheGreenMiles
Published On: 11/16/2008 12:01:52 PM

As the Bush administration tries to lock in oil and natural gas leases off the Virginia coast before President-elect Obama can take office, the Richmond Times-Dispatch offers this handy rundown of the gubernatorial contenders' positions on drilling:

Republican candidate Bob McDonnell wants to drill baby, drill.

Democratic contenders R. Creigh Deeds and Terry McAuliffe want to poke around.

And Democratic candidate Brian Moran is reluctant to dig into the deep "at this time."

Del. Moran deserves credit for taking a strong stand against drilling. Even if the Interior Dept. is right and there are 130 million barrels of recoverable oil off the Virginia coast, that would only quench America's current oil thirst for all of two weeks. And how much could be recovered without interfering with the U.S. Navy's Virginia Capes Operating Area?

"Our first priority should be alternative and renewable energy sources, not drilling for more of a 19th-century energy source," [Moran spokesman Jesse] Ferguson told the Times-Dispatch.

As for McDonnell ... I mean, did he see Jim Gilmore flop, baby, flop when he tried to score points with that line? Voters want clean energy. If McDonnell can't bring his energy policies out of the 1800s, it would be a big opening for Moran.



Comments



And with this... (elevandoski - 11/16/2008 3:00:38 PM)
Brian Moran has clinched my full and enthusiastic support.

Another Democratic prospect, Del. Brian J. Moran of Alexandria, opposes exploration for oil and gas "at this time," according to his spokesman, Jesse Ferguson.

"Our first priority should be alternative and renewable energy sources, not drilling for more of a 19th-century energy source," Ferguson said.

Ferguson also said it has not been proved that Virginia oil and gas reserves are a "long-term solution" to energy needs.

He said Moran believes offshore exploration is a potential threat to the environment and to the appeal of Virginia Beach, among other shore points, as a tourist destination.

With Governor Moran at the helm, maybe we'll concentrate instead on offshore wind which delivers not only as much as 20% of the Commonwealth's power demand and more jobs to Hampton Roads than offshore drilling but also comes at prices now comparable to dirty coal.  

Governor Moran will also join Governors in New Jersey, Maryland, and North Carolina in objecting to offshore drilling and he'll join them in hooking up all the various wind farms off our coasts to create another Atlantic strategic interconnected offshore grid system and thus relieving the pressure asserted on our existing onshore transmission corridor.



How About Other Issues (Not Harry F. Byrd, Sr. - 11/16/2008 3:55:46 PM)
How about support of a responsible gas tax?  Moran is on record last year against a $0.05 increase.  Deeds for voted for one.  I'm not sure if McAuliffe has stated a position.  The Washington Post's lead editorial today endorsed a $0.48 gas tax increase today as a responsible environmental action:

Washington Post, Raise the Gas Tax

Dominion Resources has given $13,000 to both Moran and Deeds.  There's other polluters in the Commonwealth like Smithfield, right?  Moran & Deeds have received $1500 from them. Altria is anti-environmental, right?  They gave Moran and Deeds over $20,000.  $0 to McAulliffe on all 3, but we'll see what happens.  That's got to be worth something from an environmental point of view.  

This blog put a ton of effort and energy last year into Sen. Petersen's Clean Energy Future Bill.  

http://www.raisingkaine.com/sh...
http://www.raisingkaine.com/sh...
http://www.raisingkaine.com/sh...
http://www.raisingkaine.com/sh...

Neither Moran or Deeds co-sponsored it although many others did - Sens. Edwards, Reynolds, Ticer, Whipple, & Dels. Barlow, Bouchard, Brink, Ebbin, Eisenberg, Englin, Lingamfelter, Marsden, Plum, Poisson, Scott, Toscano, Valentine & Vanderhye.

http://leg1.state.va.us/cgi-bi...

Miles - I'd like to see comparisons on other green issues also.  Do you have of the candidates' positions on any other Green issues?  



All of this is exactly why... (Lowell - 11/16/2008 3:57:46 PM)
...I'm neutral in the governor's race, and will stay that way until someone shows me that they are willing to stand up to Dominion et al.  If not, I may just sit this one out.


Altria (tx2vadem - 11/16/2008 7:03:34 PM)
all that is left of Alria is Philip Morris USA.  They sold off Philip Morris International and Kraft Foods.  Why Altria would care about stopping environmental laws?  They care about cigarette taxes and efforts to further reduce sales of their product.  I guess land use laws would be an issue for tobacco farming.


Candidates' positions (TheGreenMiles - 11/16/2008 7:05:40 PM)
I think it's a little early to pin them down on their energy plans as governor. But I'm sure they'll roll out detailed plans on their websites before the primary. And we'll get to see how they react to the Climate Commission's recommendations in the upcoming General Assembly session.


Questions (tx2vadem - 11/16/2008 7:18:29 PM)
Hey, I asked you some questions about those very recommendations in this comment.  Care to respond?


I find it troubling (realist - 11/17/2008 5:24:13 PM)
with statements like this

"Another Democratic prospect, Del. Brian J. Moran of Alexandria, opposes exploration for oil and gas "at this time," according to his spokesman, Jesse Ferguson."

Just like on transportation ignoring certain existing solutions makes no sense to this realist centrist.  

The resources are right here.  We need to do everything to get out of this mess.  wind, solar, hydro, AND nuclear, oil, gas, clean coal (yes it exists)

I echo Texas2Vadems call to see what is practical and realistic in these times of economic slowdown.        



Look at the record (David Campbell - 11/17/2008 4:23:53 PM)
Moran and Deeds have almost a decade of legislative history (McAuliffe is an unknown quantity).  According to the Virginia League of Conservation Voters, Moran and Deeds have an almost identical record of supporting the environment since 2000: Moran 83% Deeds 84%.


And (David Campbell - 11/17/2008 5:18:56 PM)
McDonnell 18%


How About HOT Lane Support (Matt H - 11/17/2008 4:36:37 PM)
No one stood up to oppose their creation (or below market financing rates that we paid for) and if you look on VPAP's site, you will see that the politicians took in tons of money from the private contractors building the HOT lanes.

HOT lanes are very regressive and instead of promoting car-pooling or public transportation, they permit the rich to drive in their own "Lexus" lanes and this does not serve the environment well.