Transportation Special Session Preview Poll

By: TheGreenMiles
Published On: 6/21/2008 1:43:12 PM

The Green Miles is a baseball stats geek. Moneyball is one of my favorite books. One of the people highlighted in Moneyball, then-Oakland A's assistant general manager Paul DePodesta, is now works in the front office of the San Diego Padres.

The Alexandria native recently became a pioneer -- a baseball executive with a blog that breaks down the thinking behind the club's moves. It's called, appropriately enough, It Might be Dangerous ... You Go First.

When discussing the skill and luck involved in making selections in baseball's draft, DePodesta posted a chart from the book Winning Decisions. I couldn't help but be reminded of the Virginia General Assembly's transportation special session that begins Monday, a process that's far from ideal with an outcome that's definitely in doubt.

So let's use that chart to make our predictions about the results of the session. First, what do you think of the process -- the session itself and the willingness of the participants to come together for the good of the Commonwealth? Second, what's your prediction for the outcome -- will transportation get the funding it needs, and if so, will the revenue source be a wise choice?

Cast your vote after the jump and give us a look at your reasoning in comments. 



Comments



Bad Process, Poetic Justice (Teddy - 6/21/2008 5:42:12 PM)
So far, that's the consensus, but based on too small a sample to be definitive. Under Bad Process, I personally would put the public position of blatant obstructionism-negativism of the Republican leadership in the House of Delegates, and the monotonous repetition of their "no tax" mantra. Could anything be better designed to gum up the process? Also, under Bad Process, I put the clear expectation of the Governor that, by holding the session and putting the Republican obstruction on public display he will achieve the political objective of being able to say "See, I did my part, gave them every chance to be part of the solution, so let's punish the Republicans in the next election by voting them out of office." Faced with such obvious political game playing on both sides, clearly the result will be Poetic Justice---- for both sides.  


Bad Process - Bad Outcome - Poetic Justice (Jim W - 6/22/2008 7:37:00 AM)

My favorite restaurant has good service and good food, not the highest prices on the menu.   As long as the transportation program is measured in dollars and the dollars are spread like peanut butter on a sandwich poetic justice will result.  

The Northern Virginia bond issue failed because of the combination of highest prices and a peanut butter project list.  The voters are looking for reduced congestion.  

Until spending is aimed at reducing congestion, the voters won't buy.  That means a plan that allocates projects based on congestion and not on dollars.  Because of higher construction costs in populated areas Northern Virginia gets half a loaf while down state gets a full loaf.