So Much for a Smoking Ban

By: Lowell
Published On: 2/15/2008 8:09:07 AM

This is pathetic:

The Virginia House of Delegates defeated several proposals Thursday to prohibit smoking in restaurants, stores, offices and other public places, effectively killing all anti-smoking legislation for this year's General Assembly session.

Sen. Ralph Northam, a doctor, sums up why we need this legislation in Virginia:

Sen. Ralph Northam, D-Norfolk, who carried the restaurant ban, said he believes the less government, the better. But the government also has a responsibility to protect its citizens.

"Specifically in restaurants, we have a regulation that tells food preparers and employees to wash their hands after they use the restroom," Northam said.

"We'd like to know that our food, that the plates that it's served on, that the glasses our beverages come in, are clean. So there's a reason for regulation," he said.

Exactly right, the government has a responsibility to protect its citizens. And cigarette smoke is a carcinogen, that is, it causes cancer. How hard is this to understand?  Apparently, it's too hard for Dave Albo:

Del. Dave Albo, R-Fairfax County, who made the motion to table and effectively kill the bills, said he's "not against doing something" but thinks the legislature needs to rework its laws regarding the definition of a restaurant first.

Currently, state law doesn't distinguish between bars and restaurants, and an establishment has to sell a certain amount of food to get its state license to sell alcoholic beverages.

"The real problem is that in the bar area, people want to smoke, in the restaurant area they don't, and our current laws don't make a distinction between a bar and a restaurant," Albo said.

Oh, c'mon now Dave, you're such a smart guy and you can't figure this one out?  I mean, it's not exactly as if you don't have examples in...oh, just about the entire United States.  That's right, people all across the country, from Arizona to Maine, have figured this out -- but you're stumped?  Sorry to be a bit skeptical, but that's a little hard to believe.  Of course, you ARE the same guy who brought us arguably the dumbest legislation in years in Virginia, the hated (and now, hopefully, dead) "abusive driver fees."  So I guess we shouldn't be surprised that you've gotten it wrong once again, this time on protecting people from cancer-causing agents in the air they breath.


Comments



maybe we should map this one out (Alter of Freedom - 2/15/2008 8:52:36 AM)
it was just the other day there was a post of how Virginia is becoming more like Maryland---after this weeks General Assembly sessions it does not seem so now does it.
Afterall Lowell this is still Virginia, ya know tobacco rich history Virginia?
It could be nice to see a state map with the House districts posted showing just where the votes are coming from in the House to defeat the bill though to get an idea of just how this issue relates to cities and rural areas in terms of an issue.


Sounds great (TheGreenMiles - 2/15/2008 9:30:09 AM)
Why don't you make the map?  :)


"AfterallLowell this is still Virginia" (Lowell - 2/15/2008 9:32:36 AM)
Wow, and all this time I thought I was in Minnesota or something.  Thanks for the clarification! :)


I wouldn't bother. (csgrzesiek - 2/15/2008 9:52:07 AM)
A map like that would be pretty bare, since 5 people on a subcomittee are the only ones who voted.  I guess you could include the Speaker as well, since he's the one who sends it to that subcommittee.


two thumbs up (West Ailsworth - 2/15/2008 8:53:03 AM)
I'm pleased with this outcome.  The market is working.  The Marriott has banned smoking in all their hotels and the restaurants inside them.  I also know several restaurant owners in Newport News who have banned smoking or enacted rules for only smoking after 9pm.  I just don't see a reason for the gov't to step in at this point.


And they left no fingerprints (TheGreenMiles - 2/15/2008 8:53:44 AM)
No recorded vote. Is there any more cowardly group in the entire Commonwealth of Virginia than the Republicans of the House?


Still wondering... (lellis - 2/16/2008 1:53:55 AM)
why there needs to be a law.

ANY restaurant is free to make their establishment nonsmoking if they want to. Any person is free to leave or not patronize a restaurant where there is smoking. It's not as if anyone is forced to go to a restaurant.



Agreed. (MikeSizemore - 2/20/2008 4:59:07 PM)
**