"Amigo Shopping" in Prince William County

By: Lowell
Published On: 10/26/2007 6:37:48 AM

The Washington Post reports this morning about a disturbing trend of violent crime against Hispanics in Prince William County (and also Montgomery County, Maryland).  According to the article, "Hispanic immigrants are being targeted, often in gratuitously violent attacks by non-Hispanics, because they are thought to carry cash rather than use banks and to be reluctant to report crimes to police." The expression used for this type of crime is "amigo shopping."

[Serafin "Pedro" Alvarez ] Negrete, the victim in the Prince William case, arrived from Mexico in 2005, moving into a room in a faded trailer park and sending money back to his wife and three children. He was walking to that room, a simple space furnished with little more than a bed with no sheets, in September 2006 when he was confronted by the teenage robbers.

At the entrance to the trailer park, Negrete was shot at least eight times. A weathered shrine marks the spot where his body fell. Fastened to a chain-link fence is a wooden cross covered with white lilies, plastic and permanent.

Georgino Napier, who was 18 at the time, and Carlito McToy, who was 17, were charged as adults with first-degree murder. They have pleaded guilty and been sentenced to 28 and 33 years in prison, respectively.

Much in the neighborhood has changed since the slaying. Overhead lighting was installed, police began to patrol the area more aggressively and residents learned to change their habits. Relatives of Negrete have returned to Mexico.

When Negrete was killed, Prince William police had already noticed a spike in robberies of immigrants. The county's crime rate in 2006 was the lowest in five years, but robberies were up 40 percent. Of the 351 reported, 83 percent were street robberies, many of which involved Latino victims.

Let's repeat that last point: crime rates are DOWN OVERALL in Prince William county (note that immigrants are LESS likely to commit crimes than non-immigrants), but robbery is UP against Hispanic immigrants ("amigo shopping").  In other words, it's the exact opposite situation of what the most vocal and vehement illegal immigration opponents claim.  In fact, a 2006 Harvard study found that "living in a neighborhood of concentrated immigration is directly associated with lower violence" -- but not, apparently, AGAINST the immigrants themselves.  So let's debate what to do about illegal immigration, but let's keep our facts straight when we do so.


Comments



another consequence (pvogel - 10/26/2007 6:52:29 AM)
Of breaking the principal of equal protection.

I bet the Prince william police will never check the status of a white european illegal



Good diary and analysis Lowell (Dianne - 10/26/2007 6:53:59 AM)
Most Virginians would be appalled by this and other racist type acts against minorities.  So I'll say again, the Democratic candidates hopefully should be talking about how this is NOT a Virginia value to single out an ethnic group to attack, threaten, or deny HUMAN rights.  It's good that RK is here to so excellently report these stories (Lowell this is really good analysis) but the word and the story needs to be taken up by those seeking to turn Virginia blue.  The vicious crowd that is against anything that isn't "my type of Christian", white, and "that's how I've always done it" need to be confronted.  The candidates need to denounce these activities and appeal to the decency of the electorate. It worked on George Allen....and it will work again.  We are changing here in Virginia.


Arlington, too (TheGreenMiles - 10/26/2007 9:59:14 AM)
Unfortunately it's not just Prince William ... my upstairs neighbor was just targeted this month ... the suspects in this attack haven't been caught, but previous arrests in my neighborhood have been people from DC, and I suspect they know immigrants are an easy target ...


Immigrants save communities money, too (Andrea Chamblee - 10/26/2007 4:54:44 PM)
I think the state of Texas knows a thing or two about immigration.  A new state report concludes they bring in huge amounts of money INTO state budgets.  Here.


Wow, that's amazing. (Lowell - 10/26/2007 4:57:53 PM)
"the absence of the estimated 1.4 million undocumented immigrants in Texas in fiscal 2005 would have been a loss to our gross state product of $17.7 billion. Undocumented immigrants produced $1.58 billion in state revenues, which exceeded the $1.16 billion in state services they received."

Once again, the anti-illegal-immigrant bashers don't know what they're talking about.



Immigrants May Drive Down Prices (PM - 10/26/2007 6:11:44 PM)
That's the theory of at least two economists.  http://www.washingto... 

For example:

Lach's thesis -- that immigration acts as a brake on inflation -- is unusual in that it explores the effect immigrants have on the demand side of an economy, and not just as workers who lower the costs of child care, for example, by increasing the labor pool.

Lach said in a new paper published in the Journal of Political Economy that immigrants tend to do what Bethesda drivers do not do often enough: They go the extra mile to the cheaper gas station. Lach found that new immigrants spend much more time comparison-shopping than natives -- perhaps because their economic circumstances force them to look for the best deals . . .

I hope more empirical work is done in this area. 



So, let's get this straight (Lowell - 10/26/2007 9:36:09 PM)
1) They increase economic activity
2) They lower prices
3) They give more back to the state than they take
4) They are associated with lower crime rates

Wow, sounds awful! *snark*