Another Achievement for Jim Webb

By: Lowell
Published On: 9/28/2007 9:18:27 AM

Sen. Webb continues to demonstrate why we all fought so hard for him last year, and why he's already turned into a leader in the U.S. Senate.  From this "modern day Truman Commission" to his "dwell time" amendment, his support for childrens' health and workers' rights, and his leadership on foreign policy, Senator Webb is doing a great job for Virginia.  Every day, I'm more proud to have worked to elect Jim Webb last year.

WEBB-MCCASKILL AMENDMENT WINS APPROVAL FOR LANDMARK WARTIME CONTRACTING ACCOUNTABILITY

"Freshman Class" legislation will crack down on defense contracting abuses

WASHINGTON, D.C. - A landmark provision sponsored by U.S. Senators Jim Webb (D-VA), Claire McCaskill (D-MO) and their seven Senate Democratic freshman colleagues won unanimous approval in the Senate today. The provision, to establish an independent, bipartisan Commission to investigate U.S. wartime contracting in Iraq and Afghanistan, was debated during consideration of the Defense Authorization Act, which authorizes funding for the U.S. Department of Defense for fiscal year 2008.

"This is an historic moment," said Webb. "On the campaign trail last year, we talked about the need to restore basic accountability to our government. We talked about the need to ensure that the federal government works in an honest and efficient manner-and that American taxpayers get real value for their investment. Today, we're one step closer to that goal."

Senator Webb continued: "Our colleagues sent an unequivocal signal that it's high time we rein in the waste, fraud and abuse in wartime contracts in Iraq and Afghanistan."


"Never before in U.S. history have we seen such waste, fraud, and abuse, costing the American people billions of dollars.  This amendment is not about politics; it's about reform.  It is about looking forward and finding a way to contract that is fiscally responsible while still protecting the strength of our military," said Senator McCaskill.

"The American taxpayer is footing the bill for the wars in Iraq and Afghanistan and we have an obligation to ensure that their money is spent only for what is necessary to equip our troops or rebuild local infrastructure.  I am deeply concerned by reports of fraud, abuse and waste, and I want to establish a mechanism -- isolated from the political process - that will ensure U.S. dollars are spent as intended," said Senator Benjamin L. Cardin.

"The evidence is clear that taxpayers are being ripped off for billions of dollars in no-bid contracts awarded to Halliburton and other firms," Senator Bernie Sanders said.  "Astonishingly, we know that $9 billion spent on private contractors in Iraq is missing. We owe it to taxpayers to take a long, hard look at the conduct of contractors."

"Tens of billions of taxpayer dollars have gone to private contractors who operate outside the rules. The result has been chaos - projects never completed, dollars never accounted for, and benchmarks never met. We have wasted too much money on private contractors, and if they can't be trusted with our dollars, then they shouldn't be doing business with this country," said Senator Sherrod Brown.

"As a former Pennsylvania Auditor General, I know firsthand the need to aggressively root out waste in government," said Senator Bob Casey.  "But it is especially egregious for companies doing business in Iraq to profit from fraud and abuse for taxpayer dollars to be lost as our troops are in harm's way."

"This proposal is long overdue," said Senator Amy Klobuchar. "Again and again we have seen contractors wastefully spend hard-working American taxpayer dollars while this Administration sat idly by - enough is enough.  When I was a county attorney, we always said, 'follow the money and you'll find the bad guys.'  This Commission will follow the money and it will make sure people are held accountable for waste, fraud, and abuse."

"Iraq is a target rich-environment for corruption, and monitoring the expenditure of U.S. resources requires vigilance," said Senator Sheldon Whitehouse.  "This Commission will ensure that the billions of dollars provided for reconstruction in Iraq are accounted for - so the hard-earned money U.S. taxpayers provide will serve the purposes we intend, for the benefit of both the American and the Iraqi people."

"For too long we've heard horror stories of waste, fraud and abuse by government contractors.  Montana taxpayers work too hard to subsidize this kind of greed," said Senator Jon Tester.  "The wars we fight and shed blood for are not for profit. This legislation brings long overdue accountability and real change to the way American contractors do business in Iraq and Afghanistan."

The commission created by this amendment will significantly increase transparency and accountability, and address longstanding, systemic problems with defense contracting by studying and investigating the impact of the government's growing reliance on civilian contractors to perform wartime functions.  Contractors in Iraq and Afghanistan now outnumber U.S. troops.

Inspired by the legacy of Harry Truman, who established a committee to fight wartime contracting abuse when he was a freshman in the U.S. Senate, the Senators' legislation creates a Commission on Wartime Contracting that will assess the extent of waste, fraud, abuse, and mismanagement of wartime contracts, and the extent to which those responsible have been held accountable.  The "Truman Committee" conducted hundreds of hearings and investigations into government waste, saving American taxpayers more than $15 billion (1943 dollars).

The modern Commission on Wartime Contracting would work in partnership with the Special Inspector General of Iraq Reconstruction (SIGIR).  The legislation expands the oversight of the SIGIR to include investigations of wartime contracting in Iraq and Afghanistan, not just Iraq reconstruction.  This expansion is in response to recent reports of contractor abuses, including the latest federal investigation of Blackwater, which had the largest contracts for private security contractors in Iraq.

Congressmen John Tierney (D-MA) introduced language similar to the Webb-McCaskill amendment in the House of Representatives today as a stand-alone bill.  The bipartisan, bicameral measure has also attracted the support of taxpayer watchdog groups including: the Project on Government Oversight, Taxpayers for Common Sense, the Government Accountability Project, OMBWatch, Common Cause, U.S. PIRG and Iraq and Afghanistan Veterans of America.

Specifically, the amendment:

  * Establishes an independent, bipartisan eight-member Commission on Wartime Contracting to study and investigate federal agency contracting for:  (1) the reconstruction of Iraq and Afghanistan; (2) the logistical support of coalition forces in Operation Iraqi Freedom and Operation Enduring Freedom; and (3) the performance of security and intelligence functions in Operation Iraqi Freedom and Operation Enduring Freedom.

  * Expands the Special Inspector General for Iraq Reconstruction's (SIGIR's) jurisdiction beyond Iraq Reconstruction and Relief Funds to other wartime contracts executed in support of either Operation Iraqi Freedom or Operation Enduring Freedom.  In consultation with the Commission, the newly-expanded SIGIR will conduct audits of wartime support contracts for logistics and security functions in Iraq and Afghanistan, as well as reconstruction contracts in Afghanistan.  The collaborative effort between the Commission, SIGIR, and the inspectors general of other federal agencies is designed to lead to specific findings and recommendations to improve inter-agency wartime contracting, among other things.

  * Requires a study and investigation into the impact of the government's growing reliance on civilian contractors to perform wartime functions.  The commission will assess the extent of waste, fraud, abuse, and mismanagement of wartime contracts, and the extent to which those responsible have been held accountable. The number of contractors (180,000) now exceeds the number of American troops in Iraq and Afghanistan (156,247).


Comments



Unanimous? (KCinDC - 9/28/2007 9:27:35 AM)
How'd that happen? I thought there was a fair amount of opposition earlier, including some from Warner.


That's a great question. (Lowell - 9/28/2007 9:35:15 AM)
I have no idea, need to find out what happened with this.  Regardless, I'm glad to see it passed!


An explanation is (Lowell - 9/28/2007 10:37:49 AM)
here:  it was a voice vote, John Warner says his concerns were addressed.


Here Are 2 Reasons (norman swingvoter - 9/28/2007 12:20:27 PM)
1) According to The Richmond-Times Dispatch, "Warner and allies won some concessions in talks over the proposal, including removing subpoena power from the independent commission."
2) The commission was supposed to issue its first report next year, now it is being issued in January 2009 after the elections.

This is still a great triumph for Jim Webb and Claire McCaskill (D-MO).  These wars have been going on without adequate oversight for way too long!



Hmm (KCinDC - 9/28/2007 1:52:13 PM)
It's good that something passed, but it does sound like it was weakened quite a bit then. Administration stonewalling is made easier, and accountability is put off for the convenience of Republican election prospects.


commission (Alice Marshall - 9/28/2007 9:49:44 AM)
a lot depends upon who is appointed to the commission. I nominate Bunnantine Greenhouse.


She'd be a great one! (vadem - 9/28/2007 9:18:01 PM)
Agreed.


I remember her story (Ron1 - 9/29/2007 1:44:31 AM)
People that live morality and honor ought to be honored more.

Besides, I like anyone named Bunny :) ! (I hate emoticons, but that one seemed appropriate.)



We Have a Senator Both Effective and Strong (Elaine in Roanoke - 9/28/2007 10:16:40 AM)
I expect that this kind of leadership is what we will see from Jim Webb year after year as Virginia's soon-to-be senior senator.

How refreshing to have someone represent me who has both integrity and great leadership qualities! It makes the work we all did in the election well worth the effort.

(I look forward to that next book, too!)



Webb shows real leadership here (Catzmaw - 9/28/2007 6:12:00 PM)
He's been knocked down a couple of times but comes up fighting each time.  This Truman commission will go a long way in reeling in contractor excesses.  Some day his dwell time amendment will come back to stay. 

I saw Webb on C-Span's replay last night of the Foreign Affairs Committee hearing on the Law of the Sea Treaty changes.  He was standing in as temporary chairman, and did a great job.  Asked a lot of questions, mostly to address potential criticisms of the treaty.  He was extremely focused, and went through the questions one after another, carefully eliciting the panel's views on each issue and speaking from the depth of knowledge that a former NavSec would have.  Can't imagine Allen doing one fourth the job.  Of course, no one would have ever made Allen the stand-in chairman of anything.  What a lightweight. 



Shifting Warfare (RobertJSmithIII - 9/28/2007 10:58:16 AM)
I think that this highlights the necessity of proceeding with warfare by carefully measuring strategy and preparing as technology and tactics change.  A prime example, the Vietnam War, as cliche as it might sound, arguably could have been the starting point for us to bolster our ability to fight insurgency while occupying a foreign state.  There were several counterinsurgency treatises released but none officially heeded or adopted by the U.S. government.  As a result, by the time we occupied Iraq, we were not prepared for the partisan fighting that we experience as a result of our operations.  Having a strong modus operandi is crucial to success.  I can only imagine that a debacle like the War In Iraq was a result of political strategy, in that the Join Chiefs of Staff, serving for the President, may have had a set agenda that precluded the expenditure of time for thorough preparation for whatever reason (support for the War on Terror by immediate action?);I cannot imagine, based on my readings in foreign affairs, how it could have possibly been overlooked that Iraq has notorious religious/cultural factions and that a dictator, a sponsor of one of those factions, had seized power and that the termination of that power by outside forces would spark partisan fighting.  The Counterinsurgency Field Manual, released in July of this year, is a thorough look at what to expect in Iraq, although written four years too late.  It should have been written in the 1970s from experience and updated, based on regional expectations, in late 2002, not in 2007.  The next step in the process, based on where we stand now, is to help establish an effective means of making sure that our country is prepared.


Cont'd (RobertJSmithIII - 9/28/2007 11:05:32 AM)
In addition, as it relates to defense contracting, a relatively new approach in warfare, restraints should have been imposed before passing authorization legislation for a relatively untested private sector of defense.  Poor preparation allowed these problems with Blackwater to occur.  We cannot decide to go to war and expect our old tactics and new, untested ones to go perfectly; methodical preparation has to be a part of the equation.  At any rate, it's difficult to determine exactly how poor preparation, as a habit or practice, began in the first place.


ok, jim... (lgb30856 - 9/28/2007 11:25:03 AM)
how bout just getting us out of this war?


Just called the Webb ofc. It really did pass unanimously !!! (Tom Counts - 9/28/2007 11:40:52 AM)
Who knew that Jim would become the Great Convincer so soon. I guess it helps to have such a powerful message, thorough knowledge and belief, and stuborness to boot.

What Jim has been doing reminds me of what the Dept. head (a Navy captain at the time) told all of us when someone asked why we sometimes had to do things that we required by Navy policy or weren't policy but we did anyway. His answer was:
We don't do things just because we are required to do them. "We do the right thing because it's the right thing to do". To me, this is the core of Jim's greatness and why I knew I had to work so hard for him last year. No one told me that I was required. I think we all understood that we were doing the right thing because it was the right thing to do.

How tremendously inspiring !

  Tom Counts
Proud, Humbled and Honored to be a Jim Webb Democrat.



then what? (JD - 9/28/2007 12:06:57 PM)
Obviously, this is a great first step.  But we all know what they say about Commissions.  Other than ensure full disclosure to the American people and provide some hard facts to campaign against, can the Commission or Inspector General of Iraq do anything tangible to STOP the fraud?  Or would that take another act of Congress?  Or a lawsuit?  I hope Congress has a strategy of what to do with negative findings.


This is really great news (Ron1 - 9/28/2007 12:14:23 PM)
There is nothing patriotic about war profiteering. One of the gaping maws that we need to look into as we recover from this disastrous war and presidency is what kind of structure we want to have for our military. "Outsourcing" and "privatization" of military functions in this war were chosen because it was the only way to have enough personnel to do the job -- if we as a country had looked honestly at what kind of personnel and monetary commitment it would have taken to topple Saddam's army and command structure, maintain relative peace and order in Iraq, seal the borders, rebuild a government/army/civilian infrastructure, and on and on and on, we would have realized it would have taken a commitment on the order of 600k or 700k, and the war would never have happened.

Instead of deciding on an enhanced containment, inspections, and disarmament regime spear-headed by international institutions, and focusing our attention on Afghanistan and Pakistan, Bush decided to plunge us into this black hole. And instead of doing the hard and dirty work of trying to convince the country to pay more taxes to increase the size and training of our war-time armed forces, Bush and his cronies decided to allow the "private sector" to take over, to disastrous result. These contractors are accountable to no one (the slogan for the Bush years!), endanger our troops, waste taxpayer money, and are often counter-productive (see Fallujah, and the recent Blackwater disaster) to the mission.

My only concern is that this 'bi-partisan' commission will temper its language and try not to affix blame to partisan characters, but I trust Senator Webb to make sure that this will not be another whitewash.

Good on ya, freshmen Senators.



Hurrah for Webb! (snolan - 9/28/2007 12:44:53 PM)
This is more like what we hoped he'd do in office and why we were so excited to help him win this seat.  Thank you Senator Webb!

I am also astonished at the sudden lack of opposition, and wonder if some of the things our senator has done recently that we found disappointing might have been part of some wheeling and dealing so he'd get support on this more crucial issue...  if so - kudos to Senator Webb.

With oversight comes knowledge and disclosure, and perhaps we'll finally take the profit out of the warmaker's bloviating.



why stop there Jim (JScott - 9/28/2007 1:43:11 PM)
Why stop with defense contracting. We should habe a government that does this for all of its major budget expenses. Example: How much fraud is there in healthcare? Should we not apply the same reasoning behind this to all the other areas that contribute the most to our spending? And Jim get the balanced budget amendment wheeling and dealing going now that the Dems will certainly have the control after November. Make that happen and we will open the Opus One and drink to you. Since the Dems will have control and they have been asking for it for years during the Republican dominated era it seems now is the time to get it done if we are really serious about fiscal responsibility.


McCaskill/Webb VERY GOOD! (TurnVirginiaBlue - 9/28/2007 4:21:01 PM)
This is what I'm talkin' about.  It's about time we get some accountability on those contracts.  They are about to raise the debt ceiling again and if anyone is paying attention, the dollar is now tanking in value.  It's outright theft what's going on.

I also like McCaskill and see that our Freshman Dems are seemingly forming a little caucus.  I sure as hell don't understand the FISA vote but this one is a great win and I'm glad I volunteered in '06 to get these guys elected.

WAY TO GO WEBB!